Bennigan’s Menu USA Prices 2026 – Calories, Hours & Best Items

Welcome to our complete guide to the Bennigan’s menu USA prices. Bennigan’s is a classic American casual-dining restaurant known for its Irish-inspired hospitality, hearty American favorites, burgers, sandwiches, chicken, salads, appetizers, desserts, and drinks.

Founded in 1976, Bennigan’s continues to combine familiar favorites with updated American fare in a warm neighborhood-pub setting. The official brand describes its food experience around chef-driven dishes, innovative drinks, friendly service, and Irish hospitality.

If you are looking for the Bennigan’s menu with prices, want to know what to order, are checking calories, or simply want to compare Bennigan’s with other American casual restaurants, this guide gives you the information in an easy-to-use format.

Important: Bennigan’s menu items, prices, portions, calories, promotions, and availability can vary by restaurant. The official menu specifically notes that local menus may differ. Always check your selected restaurant before ordering.

What’s on the Bennigan’s Menu?

Bennigan’s has a broad menu designed for everything from a quick lunch to a relaxed family dinner or drinks with friends. Depending on the location, you may find appetizers, salads, soups, sandwiches, burgers, chicken, steaks, seafood, pasta, ribs, desserts, and beverages.

The restaurant is particularly recognized for longtime favorites such as the World Famous Monte Cristo and Turkey O’Toole, which Bennigan’s continues to highlight on its current website.

Bennigan’s Menu at a Glance

Menu CategoryWhat You Can ExpectEstimated Calories*
AppetizersWings, egg rolls, mozzarella sticks, nachos, onion rings350–1,500+
SoupsFrench onion, baked potato and rotating soups200–500
SaladsChicken salads, Cobb-style salads and garden salads300–900
SandwichesReuben, Club, Monte Cristo, Turkey O’Toole600–1,400
BurgersCheeseburgers and specialty burgers700–1,300
ChickenTenders, Buffalo wings and chicken entrées500–1,200
EntréesSteak, seafood, pasta and hearty dinner plates600–1,500+
SidesFries, onion rings, vegetables and other sides150–700
DessertsCheesecake, brownie-style desserts and other sweets400–1,000+
BeveragesSoft drinks, coffee, beer and cocktails0–500+

*Calories are general estimates for planning purposes, not official nutritional values. Preparation, portion size, substitutions, sauces, dressings and location-specific recipes can change the total.

Bennigan’s Appetizers & Starters

Starting with an appetizer is one of the easiest ways to make a Bennigan’s meal more social. The menu has historically included shareable favorites such as Buffalo wings, Hogan’s Egg Rolls, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, nachos, quesadillas and loaded potato options.

AppetizerDescriptionEstimated Calories
Bennigan’s Premium Buffalo WingsCrispy wings with Buffalo sauce, dip and celery600–1,100
Boneless Buffalo WingsHand-breaded boneless chicken with sauce and dip650–1,100
Hogan’s Egg RollsChicken, corn, black beans and herbs in a crisp wrapper450–700
Mozzarella Cheese SticksFried mozzarella served with dipping sauce500–800
Irish Tower O’RingsLarge beer-battered onion rings with dipping sauces600–900
Flip’s Super Loaded NachosChips, steak, beef and bean dip, cheese, pico, jalapeños and toppings1,200–1,800
Dubliner QuesadillasChicken, cheese, spices and crispy onions in a flour tortilla700–1,000
Sheela’s Sriracha ShrimpFried shrimp with a spicy dipping sauce500–800
Cheesy Potato SkinsPotato skins with cheese, bacon and green onions500–850

For a group, wings or a mixed appetizer selection can work well. If you want something more substantial, the loaded nachos or quesadillas can function almost like a meal.

Bennigan’s Soups & Salads

For lunch, a soup-and-salad combination can be a lighter alternative to a fried entrée. Bennigan’s has featured French onion soup, baked potato soup, soup of the day, garden salad and Caesar salad, along with larger entrée salads.

Soup or SaladDescriptionEstimated Calories
French Onion SoupRich onion soup finished with cheese and bread250–450
Ultimate Baked Potato SoupCreamy potato-based soup with hearty toppings300–500
Soup of the DayRotating house soup200–500
Garden SaladFresh greens and vegetables with dressing200–450
Caesar SaladRomaine, Caesar dressing, cheese and croutons350–650
Kilkenny’s Country Chicken SaladGreens, chicken, bacon, cheese, egg and tomatoes600–900
Loaded Cobb SaladChicken, bacon, cheese, avocado, egg and vegetables650–950
Apple Pecan SaladGreens, apples, pecans, dried fruit and Bleu cheese450–750
Ultimate Buffalo Chicken SaladGreens, vegetables, Buffalo chicken and Bleu cheese600–900
Steakhouse SaladGreens, vegetables, mushrooms, Bleu cheese and sliced steak500–800

Ask for dressing on the side if you want more control over the calories in a salad.

Bennigan’s Legendary Sandwiches

Sandwiches are one of Bennigan’s strongest categories. The restaurant’s current website continues to call attention to the World Famous Monte Cristo and Turkey O’Toole, while classic menu versions have also included the Reuben, Bennigan’s Club and Original Irish Dip.

SandwichWhat It’s Known ForEstimated Calories
World Famous Monte CristoHam, turkey and cheese, batter-dipped and fried, with powdered sugar and berry preserves1,000–1,500
Turkey O’TooleTurkey, Swiss cheese, smoky honey Dijon and pretzel bun650–950
Classic ReubenCorned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing on rye700–1,000
Bennigan’s ClubTurkey, ham, bacon, cheeses, tomato and lettuce750–1,050
Original Irish DipRoast beef, caramelized onions, garlic roll, au jus and horseradish sauce700–1,000
Cajun Chicken O’TooleBlackened chicken, bacon, Swiss cheese and honey Dijon700–1,000
Crispy Chicken SandwichCrispy chicken with fresh toppings on a toasted bun650–950
Kilkenny’s Country Chicken WrapChicken, lettuce, tomato, cheese, bacon and dressing650–950

What Is the World Famous Monte Cristo?

The World Famous Monte Cristo is arguably Bennigan’s most recognizable sandwich. It combines ham, roasted turkey and Swiss and American cheeses between honey-wheat bread, then uses a batter and frying preparation before finishing it with powdered sugar and berry preserves for dipping.

It is a rich choice, so guests looking for a smaller meal can ask whether their location offers a half portion or pair it with soup or salad.

Bennigan’s Burgers

Bennigan’s burgers are a natural choice if you want a filling American pub-style meal. Current Bennigan’s On The Fly menus show the Classic Cheeseburger alongside specialty burgers such as the Spicy Chipotle Burger.

BurgerDescriptionEstimated Calories
Classic CheeseburgerBeef patty, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickle700–1,000
Spicy Chipotle BurgerDouble burger, Pepper Jack, spicy slaw and chipotle aioli900–1,300
Irish Whiskey Glazed Prime BurgerSignature burger with whiskey-inspired glaze and toppings850–1,200
BBQ Bacon Cheddar BurgerBurger with barbecue flavor, bacon and cheddar850–1,200
Guinness Glazed Bacon BurgerBacon burger with a rich Guinness-inspired glaze850–1,250

Burger calories can rise significantly when cheese, bacon, creamy sauces or fries are included.

Chicken, Wings & Tenders

Chicken remains a popular option for both dine-in and takeout. Current Bennigan’s On The Fly ordering menus list signature chicken tenders, bone-in wings and boneless Buffalo wings in multiple quantities.

Chicken ItemTypical OptionsEstimated Calories
Signature Chicken Tenders3, 5, 6 or larger portions depending on location450–1,000
Boneless Buffalo WingsMultiple piece counts with sauce and dip500–1,200
Premium Bone-In WingsMultiple piece counts with sauce and ranch450–1,200
Lina’s Crispy Chicken SandwichCrispy chicken, Pepper Jack, Sriracha aioli and slaw800–1,100
Kilkenny’s Chicken SaladCrispy or grilled chicken with salad toppings600–900
Cajun Chicken O’TooleBlackened chicken with bacon, Swiss and honey Dijon700–1,000

For a lower-calorie approach, grilled chicken, lighter dressing and sauce on the side can make a substantial difference.

Bennigan’s Entrées

Depending on the restaurant, Bennigan’s dinner selections can include steak, seafood, chicken, pasta and other hearty American entrées. Menu availability varies considerably by location, so it is best to confirm the current selection with your local restaurant.

Entrée StyleExamplesEstimated Calories
SteakFlat iron steak and steakhouse-style plates600–1,200
SeafoodSalmon, shrimp and fish selections500–1,000
ChickenGrilled, Cajun or specialty chicken dishes550–1,100
PastaCreamy or tomato-based pasta with meat or seafood800–1,400
RibsSlow-cooked ribs with sauce and sides900–1,500
Fish & ChipsBeer-battered fish with fries900–1,300

Bennigan’s Sides

A side can turn a sandwich into a complete meal, but it can also add substantial calories.

SideEstimated Calories
French Fries300–500
Cheese Fries450–650
Bacon Cheese Fries550–750
Chili Cheese Fries550–800
Beer-Battered Onion Rings450–700
Bacon Ranch Fries500–750
Side Garden Salad150–300
Side Caesar Salad250–450
Seasonal Vegetable Side100–300

Current Bennigan’s On The Fly menus list French fries, cheese fries, chili cheese fries, bacon cheese fries, onion rings and bacon ranch fries among the available sides.

Bennigan’s Desserts

Save room if you have a sweet tooth. Bennigan’s dessert offerings can vary by location, but familiar choices include New York cheesecake and brownie-based desserts.

DessertDescriptionEstimated Calories
New York CheesecakeRich cheesecake with strawberry topping500–800
Brownie Bottom PieChocolate brownie-style dessert with ice cream and toppings700–1,000
Bread PuddingWarm, rich bread pudding with sauce500–800
Mini Dessert BitesSmaller sweet portions, where available250–600

The current ordering menus show New York Cheesecake with strawberry topping at participating Bennigan’s On The Fly locations.

Bennigan’s Drinks & Beverage Menu

Bennigan’s beverage choices vary by location. Soft drinks, coffee, specialty beverages, beer and cocktails may be available depending on the restaurant.

The brand’s beverage materials have included traditional beers such as Guinness, Bass, Blue Moon, Bud Light, Corona, Heineken, Michelob Ultra and Stella Artois, as well as mixed beer combinations.

Beverage TypeExamplesEstimated Calories
WaterBottled water0
Diet Soft DrinkDiet Coke or similar0–10
Regular Soft DrinkCoke, Sprite and similar120–250
CoffeeHot brewed coffee5–150
BeerDomestic or imported beer90–250+
CocktailsSpecialty mixed drinks150–500+

Alcoholic beverage availability and selections are location-dependent.

Popular Bennigan’s Menu Items

If it is your first time at Bennigan’s, these are some of the most recognizable choices to consider:

  1. World Famous Monte Cristo – the signature sandwich and one of the restaurant’s best-known legacy dishes.
  2. Turkey O’Toole – a classic turkey-and-Swiss sandwich with smoky honey Dijon.
  3. Classic Reuben – a traditional choice for corned beef fans.
  4. Signature Chicken Tenders – an easy choice for adults and families.
  5. Buffalo Wings – useful for sharing or pairing with drinks.
  6. Classic Cheeseburger – a straightforward American pub favorite.
  7. Kilkenny’s Country Chicken Salad – a heartier salad option.
  8. New York Cheesecake – a simple dessert choice.

The official Bennigan’s site specifically continues to highlight the Monte Cristo and Turkey O’Toole among its longtime favorites.

Best Bennigan’s Choices for Different Cravings

If You Want…Try…
A signature Bennigan’s experienceWorld Famous Monte Cristo
A classic Irish-American sandwichTurkey O’Toole
A traditional deli-style mealClassic Reuben
A burgerClassic Cheeseburger
Something shareableBuffalo Wings or Loaded Nachos
ChickenSignature Chicken Tenders
A saladKilkenny’s Country Chicken Salad
A lighter directionGarden Salad with grilled protein
A sweet finishNew York Cheesecake
A drink with pub atmosphereBeer or a location-specific specialty drink

Bennigan’s Menu Prices

Bennigan’s does not have one universal U.S. price list because restaurants can have different menus and pricing. The official website states that menu availability and pricing may vary by location.

For reference, current Bennigan’s On The Fly online menus show examples such as a Classic Cheeseburger around $14.99, Crispy Chicken Sandwich around $15.99, Signature Chicken Tenders around $11.99 and World Famous Monte Cristo around $15.99 at participating locations. These are examples rather than nationwide prices.

CategoryTypical Price Range*
Appetizers$7–$18+
Soups & Salads$5–$16+
Sandwiches$12–$18+
Burgers$14–$20+
Chicken$11–$25+
Entrées$16–$30+
Sides$4–$9
Desserts$4–$9
Soft Drinks$3–$5
Beer & CocktailsVaries by location

*Approximate ranges for planning. Actual prices can be different at individual restaurants.

How to Order From Bennigan’s

Bennigan’s provides several ways to enjoy its food, depending on the restaurant.

1. Dine In

Use the official location finder to choose a nearby Bennigan’s and confirm dine-in service. The current locations page identifies dine-in service at participating full-service restaurants.

2. Order Pickup

Some Bennigan’s restaurants and Bennigan’s On The Fly locations offer pickup. Select your location first so you see the menu and pricing available there.

3. Order Delivery

Participating restaurants may offer delivery through their online ordering partners. Availability depends on your location.

4. Call Your Local Restaurant

Calling can be useful when you need to confirm substitutions, allergies, group orders, catering-style requests, or item availability.

5. Check Before You Visit

Because Bennigan’s menus and prices vary by restaurant, checking the location first is the safest way to avoid surprises.

Official Bennigan’s website: Bennigans.com
Official menu: Bennigan’s Menu
Find a location: Bennigan’s Locations

Bennigan’s Locations in the USA

Bennigan’s has a smaller U.S. footprint than many national casual-dining chains, with full-service restaurants and Bennigan’s On The Fly locations. The official locations page currently lists U.S. operations in states including Kansas, Idaho and Illinois, with additional locations and development activity elsewhere.

Because restaurants open, close, relocate and change service models, use the official location finder for the latest restaurant information.

Location InformationDetails
U.S. Restaurant TypeFull-service Bennigan’s restaurants
Alternative FormatBennigan’s On The Fly
Dine-InAvailable at participating full-service locations
PickupAvailable at participating locations
DeliveryAvailable at participating locations
Location FinderOfficial Bennigan’s locations page
International LocationsSeparate from U.S. locations

The current official locations page also lists several future development locations, so the footprint can change over time.

Bennigan’s Opening Hours

There is no single nationwide Bennigan’s opening-hours schedule. Hours are set by individual restaurants and can change for holidays, special events, staffing and local operating requirements.

DayTypical Casual-Dining ScheduleWhat to Check
MondayLocation dependentLocal restaurant
TuesdayLocation dependentLocal restaurant
WednesdayLocation dependentLocal restaurant
ThursdayLocation dependentLocal restaurant
FridayLocation dependentLocal restaurant
SaturdayLocation dependentLocal restaurant
SundayLocation dependentLocal restaurant

Always check the specific Bennigan’s location before traveling, especially on holidays.

Bennigan’s Discounts, Coupons & Promotions

Promotions can change throughout the year. Bennigan’s maintains a Current Promotions section where the brand publishes active offers and seasonal promotions.

Potential ways to save include:

  • Check the current promotions page before ordering.
  • Join the Bennigan’s E-Club when available.
  • Watch for seasonal food and beverage promotions.
  • Check your local restaurant for location-specific specials.
  • Look for combination meals or limited-time offers.
  • Compare pickup pricing with delivery pricing where applicable.
  • Ask whether a participating location accepts a current promotional offer before placing your order.

Past Bennigan’s promotions have included gift-card bonuses and seasonal offers, but old promotions should not be assumed to be active today.

Current promotions: Bennigan’s Promotions

Bennigan’s Gift Cards

A Bennigan’s gift card can be a convenient choice for birthdays, holidays, coworkers, restaurant fans and casual-dining gifts.

The official Bennigan’s website provides access to gift-card information and a Check Your Gift Card Balance option.

Before buying or using a gift card, check the current terms and participating-location information because restaurant participation can vary.

Service Options

Service OptionAvailability
Dine-InAvailable at participating full-service restaurants
TakeoutAvailable at participating locations
PickupAvailable at participating locations
DeliveryAvailable at participating locations
Online OrderingAvailable at participating locations
Bennigan’s On The FlyAvailable at selected locations

The official location directory specifically distinguishes dine-in, delivery and pickup services at participating restaurants.

Bennigan’s Highlights

  • More than 50 years of brand history
  • Irish-inspired hospitality
  • American casual-dining favorites
  • World Famous Monte Cristo
  • Turkey O’Toole
  • Burgers and sandwiches
  • Chicken tenders and wings
  • Salads and soups
  • Desserts and beverages
  • Full-service restaurant locations
  • Bennigan’s On The Fly locations
  • Dine-in, pickup and delivery at participating restaurants

Bennigan’s opened its first restaurant in Atlanta in 1976 and has built its identity around food, hospitality and neighborhood gathering.

Popular For

Bennigan’s is popular for:

  • Casual family meals
  • American comfort food
  • Burgers and sandwiches
  • The Monte Cristo
  • Pub-style appetizers
  • Wings and chicken
  • Lunch meetings
  • Dinner with friends
  • Watching sports or relaxing with drinks at participating locations
  • Celebrating birthdays and casual occasions

Offerings

OfferingDetails
FoodAmerican comfort food and pub favorites
Signature ItemsMonte Cristo and Turkey O’Toole
AppetizersWings, egg rolls, nachos, quesadillas and more
SandwichesReuben, Club, Monte Cristo and Turkey O’Toole
BurgersClassic and specialty burgers
SaladsChicken, Cobb, garden and specialty salads
ChickenTenders, wings and sandwiches
EntréesLocation-dependent steak, seafood, pasta and chicken
DessertsCheesecake and other sweet selections
DrinksSoft drinks, coffee, beer and cocktails at participating locations

Dining Options

Bennigan’s works well for several dining occasions:

  • Breakfast: Generally not the primary focus of the brand.
  • Lunch: Sandwiches, salads, soups and lighter combinations are convenient choices.
  • Dinner: Burgers, chicken, steaks, seafood and hearty entrées.
  • Family dining: A broad menu makes it easier for groups to choose different dishes.
  • Casual drinks: Participating locations offer bar and beverage selections.
  • Takeout: Available at participating restaurants.
  • Delivery: Available at participating locations.

Crowd

Bennigan’s generally appeals to a broad casual-dining crowd, including:

  • Families
  • Couples
  • Friends
  • Coworkers
  • Casual lunch guests
  • Sports and pub-style diners
  • Longtime Bennigan’s fans
  • Guests looking for nostalgic American restaurant favorites

Amenities

Amenities vary by restaurant, but participating Bennigan’s locations may offer:

  • Full-service dining
  • Bar seating
  • Indoor seating
  • Takeout
  • Pickup
  • Delivery
  • Online ordering
  • Restrooms
  • Group-friendly seating

Check your specific location because not every restaurant offers the same services.

Atmosphere

The Bennigan’s atmosphere is built around a welcoming neighborhood-pub concept, combining American food with Irish hospitality. The brand describes its restaurants as warm, inviting spaces focused on food, drinks and gathering with friends.

That makes Bennigan’s suitable for a relaxed lunch, casual dinner, drinks after work or a meal with family and friends.

Payments

Accepted payment methods can vary by location and ordering platform. Most U.S. restaurants generally accept major credit and debit cards, while online orders may offer additional payment methods.

For gift cards, promotional credits or other special payment types, confirm acceptance with the restaurant before ordering.

Children

Bennigan’s broad menu can work well for families, with familiar choices such as chicken tenders, burgers, fries and other approachable dishes. Family suitability, children’s menu availability and seating arrangements can vary by location.

If you are dining with young children, contact the restaurant ahead of time if you need high chairs, booster seating or specific accommodations.

Planning Your Visit

A little planning can make your Bennigan’s visit easier.

For lunch: Consider a soup, salad or sandwich if you want a quicker meal.

For dinner: Burgers, chicken, steak, seafood or a signature sandwich provide more substantial choices.

For groups: Start with shareable appetizers such as wings, egg rolls, quesadillas or nachos.

For first-time visitors: The Monte Cristo is the most obvious signature choice, while the Turkey O’Toole offers another classic Bennigan’s experience.

For calorie-conscious diners: Look for grilled protein, vegetables, salad, lighter dressing and sauces on the side.

For delivery: Check the online menu for your exact restaurant because the delivery menu may be different from the full dine-in menu.

Parking

Parking depends on the individual Bennigan’s property. Many suburban or standalone locations may have dedicated or shared parking, while restaurants in urban areas may use street parking, garages or nearby lots.

Check the specific restaurant’s location details before visiting.

Pets

Pet policies vary by property. Pets are generally subject to local health regulations indoors, while some restaurants may have outdoor seating where pets are permitted.

If you want to bring a dog, call the specific Bennigan’s location first and ask whether its outdoor seating is pet-friendly.

Bennigan’s and Other American Restaurant Menus

If you enjoy casual American dining, you may also want to compare Bennigan’s with other restaurant menus on our site:

For sandwiches and casual lunch alternatives, see:

For burgers, you can also compare:

For steakhouse alternatives:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is Bennigan’s best-known menu item?

The World Famous Monte Cristo is one of Bennigan’s signature and most recognizable menu items. Bennigan’s also continues to highlight the Turkey O’Toole as a longtime favorite.

2. How much does Bennigan’s cost?

Prices vary by restaurant. As a general guide, sandwiches and burgers may fall around the mid-teens, while appetizers, entrées, desserts and drinks have their own location-specific pricing. Current Bennigan’s On The Fly menus show examples around $15–$16 for several popular sandwiches and burgers.

3. Does Bennigan’s have a Monte Cristo?

Yes. The World Famous Monte Cristo remains one of Bennigan’s signature dishes and is featured by the brand as a longtime favorite.

4. Does Bennigan’s offer delivery?

Participating Bennigan’s restaurants offer delivery, while other locations may offer pickup or dine-in only. The official locations page identifies available service options by restaurant.

5. Does Bennigan’s have vegetarian options?

Some menu categories can be adapted without meat, such as certain salads, sides or appetizers, but availability varies by restaurant. Ask the location about ingredients and preparation before ordering.

6. Are Bennigan’s calories available?

The calories in this guide are estimates intended for general meal planning. Bennigan’s menu items and recipes can vary by location, and the official menu also notes that menu availability varies. For dietary needs, ask your local restaurant for current nutritional and ingredient information.

7. Does Bennigan’s accept gift cards?

Bennigan’s provides gift-card information and a gift-card balance-check option through its official website. Terms and participating locations should be confirmed before use.

Bennigan’s Social Media & Official Resources

Bennigan’s maintains social channels and uses them to share food photography, restaurant news, promotions and brand updates. Legendary Restaurant Brands specifically directs guests toward Bennigan’s Facebook, Instagram and Twitter presence.

About Bennigan’s

Bennigan’s began in Atlanta, Georgia, in 1976 and became one of the recognizable names in American casual dining. Today, the brand describes itself as a neighborhood restaurant and tavern centered on chef-driven food, innovative drinks and Irish hospitality.

The brand has also expanded beyond the traditional full-service restaurant model through Bennigan’s On The Fly, giving some guests access to pickup and delivery-focused locations.

Final Words

Bennigan’s remains a good option when you want a relaxed American meal with a little more personality than a standard fast-food restaurant. Its menu brings together classic sandwiches, burgers, wings, chicken, salads, hearty entrées, desserts and drinks, while signature dishes such as the World Famous Monte Cristo and Turkey O’Toole preserve the brand’s long-running identity.

If you’re visiting for the first time, the Monte Cristo is the obvious signature experience. For something more familiar, try the Classic Cheeseburger, Signature Chicken Tenders or Classic Reuben. For a lighter meal, a salad with grilled protein or soup-and-salad combination can be a better fit.

Because Bennigan’s menu prices, hours, services and availability vary by location, check your restaurant before ordering. That is especially important when looking for current prices, nutrition information, promotions, delivery, gift-card acceptance or holiday hours.

Menu USA Prices: This guide is designed to help U.S. diners understand Bennigan’s menu choices, estimated calories, pricing ranges, ordering options and restaurant services in one place.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *